Us Weekly has affiliate partnerships so we may receive compensation for some links to products and services.
Editor’s note: This article was last updated on December 8, 2023.
Looking for the best hypoallergenic eyeliners in all of beauty? We get it. Sensitive eyes can make makeup a pain — sometimes even literally. If you apply eyeliner and your eyes start tearing, itching, turning red and stinging, you may need to start specifically shopping for hypoallergenic options instead. You could be having a reaction (contact dermatitis) to an ingredient. Same goes for if you wear contacts!
We’re talking liners with clean ingredients from trustworthy brands that design their cosmetics specifically to have fewer potential allergens. We’ll get more into what that means below.
How Did We Pick the Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliners?
It’s important to note that there are no specific guidelines or standards brands must follow to call their products “hypoallergenic.” That’s why we made sure to closely examine the ingredients for what was included — and what wasn’t. For example, it’s best to avoid common allergens like parabens, phthalates, sulfates, artificial synthetic fragrances, mineral oil, talc, formaldehyde and carbon black, as explained by Dr. Jaimie Glick.
If you specifically think you may have an allergy, it’s also great to find the phrase “allergy-tested” on the label. “Allergy-tested [means] the brand must pass a 50-person Human Repeated Insult Patch Test,” according to cosmetic chemist Ginger King!
Of course, we also searched for different types of eyeliners! Liquid, gel, pencil, black, colorful, metallic, etc. Check out our finds below!
11 of the Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliners
1. Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner
For a Tear-Free Cat Eye
Jessica Alba‘s incredible clean beauty brand did it again with this liquid liner. It has a thin tip so you can nail that winged cat eye, claiming to last up to eight hours without smudging or flaking. It’s specifically labeled hypoallergenic, leaving parabens, carbon black pigment, silicones and PEGs out of the formula!
Pros:
- Dermatologist-tested, ophthalmologist-tested, EGW-certified
- 100% tree-free paper carton
Cons:
- Eight-hour wear time isn’t as long as some other liners
Available at: Ulta
2. Almay Eyeliner Pencil
Ultra-Affordable Find
This smooth mechanical pencil’s got it all: a super low price, a built-in sharpener and a hypoallergenic, clean bill of health. It’s free of fragrance and it’s even made with vitamin E, making it super skin-friendly!
Pros:
- Dermatologist-tested, ophthalmologist-tested
- Cruelty-free
Cons:
- Hard to find all color options
3. W3ll People Fresh Lines Liquid Eyeliner
Soothing Formula
This felt-tip liquid liner is infused with plant-based ingredients like aloe and rosemary specifically to soothe delicate and sensitive eyes and skin. We love this eyeliner because it was actually dermatologist-developed!
Pros:
- Free of parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrance, gluten and animal products
- Water-resistant and smudge-resistant
Cons:
- May be more difficult to use for liquid liner beginners
4. Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil
Velvety Smooth
Some eyeliner pencils require a heavy hand, which just ends up leaving your eyes irritated. This one, however, glides on “like velvet” and includes a calming mix of chamomile, meadowfoam and vitamin E. We love Mineral Fusion because we can shop confidently knowing all of the brand’s products are hypoallergenic!
Pros:
- Free of parabens, phthalates, gluten, fragrance, talcum and other toxic ingredients
- Five shades
Cons:
- Needs a sharpener (not included)
5. LA PURE Waterproof Eyeliner Stamp
Our Stamp of Approval
Have trouble with winging your liner? It’s tough, even with years of experience! That’s why we’re obsessed with eyeliner pens that have built-in wing stamps. So easy! You even get two of these double-sided pens per purchase!
Pros:
- 100% waterproof
- Available in two sizes
Cons:
- Black is the only available shade
Available at: Amazon
6. ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner
The Best of Both Worlds
This clean liner was designed to have “the precision of a pencil with the ease of a gel.” We love how ILIA specifically explains why this liner opts for charcoal rather than carbon black, noting how carbon black “should be avoided whenever possible”!
Pros:
- Free of carbon black, gluten and cyclomethicone
- Blendable, but budge-proof once set
Cons:
- Only comes in two shades
7. Wander Beauty Skyliner Automatic Gel Eyeliner
Highly-Pigmented, Highly-Recommended
This gel pencil liner is made with jojoba seed oil and olive fruit oil to “hydrate and soothe the upper and lower lash line.” It’s creamy, cruelty-free and free of fragrance, gluten, parabens and phthalates. Shoppers say they’re “obsessed”!
Pros:
- Built-in sharpener
- Three shades, including a pretty plum
Cons:
- Over $20
Available at: Dermstore, Amazon, Walmart
8. Pixi by Petra Endless Silky Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner
Going for the Gold
This hypoallergenic, metallic liner pencil is made with no mineral oils, preservatives, formaldehyde, phthalates and more. We love the Pure24K shade for some serious glam, but we also love that it’s not the only option!
Pros:
- Waterproof
- 10 color options
Cons:
- One shopper noted they ran out quickly
Available at: Target
9. Charlotte Tilbury Eye Colour Magic Liner Duo
Double the Fun
Two colors in one pencil? Yes, please! Save space on your vanity and make your eyes seriously pop. This two-sided liner is ophthalmologically-tested and has a very high “sensitive skin friendly” rating in the reviews. The matte and metallic color combinations are just the best!
Pros:
- Smudge-proof, waterproof, humidity-proof — claims to last up to 16 hours
- Shoppers say each side is “smooth as melted butter”
Cons:
- Does contain mica
Available at: Charlotte Tilbury, Sephora
10. Glossier No. 1 Pencil
Coolest Colors
Who doesn’t love a little Glossier? This demi-matte liner is buildable and blendable, and while it’s soft, it’s sharp enough for precise wings. It’s specifically labeled “suitable for sensitive eyes” — even on your waterline. It’s safe for contacts too!
Pros:
- Dermatologist-tested, ophthalmologist-tested
- 10 colors
Cons:
- Water-resistant but not waterproof
Available at: Glossier, Sephora
11. Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
Allergy-Tested
If you know or think you have an allergy to many eyeliners, then we’d have to recommend this oil-free one. It’s allergy-tested! It’s also ophthalmologist-tested and dermatologist-tested, approved for those with sensitive eyes and contacts. And yes, it’s free of parabens, phthalates and sulfates!
Pros:
- Comes with precision brush
- Up to 24-hour waterproof wear
Cons:
- Using an eyeliner pot and brush may take practice
Available at: Target, Amazon, Ulta
Other Hypoallergenic Eyeliners We Love
- tarte Double Take Eyeliner
- SHANY Chunky Eyeshadow Eye Pencil
- Physicians Formula Eye Booster Waterproof Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner
Looking for more of our recommended picks? Check out other products below:
- The Best Self Tanners for Pale Skin That Won’t Turn You Bright Orange
- Our Picks: The Best Hypoallergenic Earrings for Sensitive Ears
- Best Hot Rollers & Curlers
See more Us Weekly Shopping
Us Weekly has affiliate partnerships. We receive compensation when you click on a link and make a purchase. Learn more!
